The Hardest Fight: Generational Wealth and the Myth of Meritocracy
STOP SCROLLING.
Over the next 20 years, roughly $84 trillion will pass from Baby Boomers to their heirs. It will be the largest transfer of wealth in human history.
Now ask the uncomfortable question:
How much of that $84 trillion will reach you?
For most Americans, the answer is simple: none.
Nearly half of this historic windfall will go to just 1% of families, while roughly half of Americans will inherit nothing. No property. No financial cushion. No head start. Just the same economic barriers their parents struggled to overcome.
We call America a land of opportunity. But opportunity increasingly looks less like achievement and more like inheritance.
This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
The Birth Lottery Nobody Talks About
We are taught that success comes from talent, discipline, and hard work. That story feels good. It just isn’t fully true.
The strongest predictor of your economic future in America is not your intelligence, effort, or education.
It’s your parents’ wealth.
Two children can work equally hard, make equally smart decisions, and still arrive at radically different outcomes because one begins life with invisible advantages:
Elite schooling and private tutoring
Professional networks and insider opportunities
Financial safety nets that allow risk-taking
Help with home down payments
Freedom from medical debt
Time to pursue unpaid internships or advanced education
Meanwhile, millions of others start adulthood carrying student loans, unstable housing, healthcare insecurity, and financial stress that compounds over decades.
This isn’t a race where some runners start ahead.
It’s a race where some participants begin miles behind the starting line.
The Numbers Behind the Inequality
$84 trillion expected intergenerational wealth transfer
Top 1% receives nearly 48% of inherited wealth
Bottom 50% inherits essentially nothing
Median household wealth:
White households: $189,100
Black households: $24,100
Around 60% of wealth among the top 0.1% is inherited
Estate tax applies only above $13.61 million, meaning 99.9% of estates pay nothing
Only about 2,000 estates per year trigger the tax
Unrealized investment gains pass tax-free to heirs through the stepped-up basis loophole, costing roughly $40 billion annually
Even equally talented children earn dramatically different incomes depending on family wealth.
Merit matters. But inheritance often matters more. Modern dynastic wealth doesn’t rely on luck. It relies on structure.
How Wealth Reproduces Itself: The Data Is Devastating
1. The Stepped-Up Basis Loophole
If an investor sells an asset during life, capital gains taxes apply.
If that same asset is passed through inheritance, its taxable gain resets to zero.
The appreciation simply disappears from the tax system.
This single rule quietly protects billions in untaxed wealth every year.
2. Dynasty Trusts
Ultra-wealthy families place assets into trusts designed to last generations. Because ownership technically never changes hands, taxation can be minimized indefinitely.
Wealth compounds. Taxes shrink. Inequality widens
3. Family Offices
At extreme wealth levels, families operate private financial institutions staffed by lawyers, accountants, and tax strategists dedicated to preserving fortunes across generations.
Entry cost: roughly $100 million in assets.
Outcome: effective tax rates often lower than those paid by middle-class workers.
The Racial Wealth Gap: History That Still Pays Interest
Today’s wealth inequality didn’t appear randomly.
Policies shaped it.
For decades, Black Americans were excluded from the primary wealth-building tools of the 20th century:
Slavery and Jim Crow blocked asset accumulation for generations
Redlining prevented home ownership and equity growth
GI Bill benefits were unevenly distributed after World War II
Housing equity became the foundation of middle-class wealth. Families allowed to buy homes built assets and passed them down. Families excluded were locked out of compounding gains.
The effects didn’t end in the past. They compound into the present.
Median Household Wealth by Race (2024)
White households: $189,100
Black households: $24,100
Hispanic households: $36,200
The gap is WIDENING, not closing
Why the Gap Exists
Slavery and Jim Crow:
Black families couldn’t accumulate wealth for 350+ years
White families had 350+ years of compounding wealth
Redlining (1930s-1968):
FHA explicitly refused to insure mortgages in Black neighborhoods
Result: Black families couldn’t buy homes, build equity
White families bought homes, built equity, passed to children
Home equity is THE primary wealth-building tool for middle class
GI Bill Discrimination (1944-1956):
Post-WWII, GI Bill helped millions buy homes, attend college
Black veterans systematically denied benefits
VA loans refused in Black neighborhoods
White veterans built wealth; Black veterans left behind
Example: How Policy Created the Wealth Gap
1950: Two veterans, one white (Jim), one Black (John)
Jim uses GI Bill, buys home for $10,000, passes to daughter ($200K by 2000)
John denied loan, rents forever, passes nothing
Jim’s grandkids: $200K down payment inheritance, buy homes
John’s grandkids: Renting, no inheritance, no equity building
This isn’t history—it’s CURRENT wealth gap caused by historical policy
This Threatens Democracy
Extreme inherited wealth doesn’t just create economic inequality. It concentrates power.
Political influence follows money. When fortunes persist across generations, influence does too.
History’s thinkers understood this risk:
Thomas Jefferson warned against hereditary economic power.
Adam Smith feared rent-seeking elites.
Theodore Roosevelt supported estate taxation to prevent fortunes growing beyond democratic balance.
Democracy depends on mobility. Aristocracy depends on inheritance.
A society cannot indefinitely sustain both.
The Mobility Problem
America often celebrates itself as uniquely upwardly mobile.
Data suggests otherwise.
The United States ranks near the bottom among developed nations in economic mobility. Countries like Denmark, Canada, and Australia offer stronger chances of moving up the income ladder.
The American Dream still exists.
It’s just increasingly inherited.
Restoring Opportunity, Not Punishing Success
The debate is often framed as envy versus achievement. That framing misses the point.
The real question is whether opportunity itself should be inherited.
Possible reforms frequently discussed include:
Immediate Reforms (Year 1)
Close the Stepped-Up Basis Loophole
Eliminate tax-free basis reset on inheritance
Heirs pay capital gains tax on unrealized gains above $1 million
Exemption for family farms/small businesses (real ones, not billionaire loophole)
Revenue: $40 billion/year
Restore Estate Tax
Lower exemption from $13.61M to $3.5M (Obama-era level)
Increase top rate from 40% to 55% for estates above $50M
Close dynasty trust loopholes
Revenue: $80 billion/year
Baby Bonds Program
Every child born in US receives government-funded trust
Amount based on family income (more for poor families)
Can access at age 18 for education, home down payment, business start
Cost: $60 billion/year (funded by estate tax increases)
Medium-Term Reforms (Years 2-5)
Reparations Through Direct Wealth Building
Progressive Property Tax Reform
Universal Childcare and Pre-K
Long-Term Reforms (Years 5+)
Constitutional Amendment on Wealth Concentration
Sovereign Wealth Fund (Alaska Model)
Education Equity Funding
The Real Choice Ahead
Generational wealth inequality forces a national decision:
Do we want a society where success depends primarily on effort and innovation?
Or one where economic position increasingly resembles a family title passed down through bloodlines?
The largest wealth transfer in history is already underway.
The only question left is whether it expands opportunity or locks it away.
Counterarguments Demolished
Myth #1: “People should be able to pass their wealth to their kids”
Reality: They CAN—up to $13.61 million tax-free. We’re only talking about taxing the ultra-wealthy. Also, their kids didn’t earn it—why should unearned wealth get preferential treatment?
Myth #2: “Estate taxes hurt family farms and small businesses”
Reality: Only 50 farms nationwide paid ANY estate tax in 2023. The “family farm” argument is a lobbying talking point used by billionaires.
Myth #3: “This is class warfare / punishing success”
Reality: The only warfare is billionaires hoarding wealth while workers can’t afford rent. Also, heirs didn’t “succeed”—they won the birth lottery.
SERIES CONNECTIONS
Episode #4 (Inequality): Generational wealth is the MECHANISM of inequality transmission
Episode #17 (Corporate Capture): Inherited wealth = inherited political power (See the series overview; episode may be upcoming)
Episode #18 (Social Security): Baby Bonds provide alternative to inherited wealth (See the series overview; episode may be upcoming)
