POWER WITH PURPOSE
Theodore Roosevelt’s Lost Leadership Style vs. The Three Trumps (2017–2026)
Prologue *This Post · Pt 1 (Live Mar 24) · Pt 2 (Live Mar 25)· Pt 3 (Live Mar 26)
The Audition
Trump’s first term was loud, chaotic, and constantly on fire. It also had guardrails. That’s the part everyone forgot… because the chaos was the point. While the country argued about the tweets, the donor class got the policy. And when it was over, the system thought it had won. It hadn’t. It had just given a very patient man four years to take notes.
By Rxan Smith · March 2026 · Uncomfortable
“I alone can fix it.”
— Donald Trump, Republican National Convention, July 2016
In This Piece
What He Inherited and What He Was
The Tax Bill: The Heist Nobody Called a Heist
Every Promise He Broke (And Who Benefited From the Breaking)
The Chaos Was Governance
The Judiciary: The Only Thing That Was Never For You
COVID: The Stress Test He Failed on Purpose
January 6 and the Exit Wound
What the System Thought It Won
And Finally…
What He Inherited and What He Was
January 20, 2017. A man who had never held public office, never served in uniform, never sat through a budget negotiation or a classified briefing placed his hand on a Bible and became the most powerful person on earth.
The press called it unprecedented. His voters called it the point.
Here’s what nobody said loudly enough: the system that let this happen wasn’t broken. It was working exactly as designed. The Electoral College did its job. Congress did its job. The courts would do theirs. The guardrails were in place.
Roosevelt’s insight — the one that defined his entire presidency — was that power must be directed. That the state is a machine, and a machine without a directed purpose doesn’t stay neutral. It gets captured. So he used power first, before the capturers could, and aimed it at the capturers themselves.
Trump’s insight, arriving 116 years later, was the inverse: you don’t need to direct state power toward a purpose. You just need to control who it’s pointed at. The machine doesn’t need to build anything. It just needs to be aimed.
That distinction is what the entire first term was.
The Tax Bill: The Heist Nobody Called a Heist
December 22, 2017. Trump signs the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act — the largest corporate tax cut in American history. Corporate rate slashed from 35% to 21%. Permanent. Individual cuts for working people? Expiring in 2025.
The corporate cuts are forever. Yours were always scheduled to disappear. That asymmetry was not an accident. It was the bill.
The administration promised a $4,000 to $9,000 annual raise for the average American worker. What the data actually shows: according to economists at the Federal Reserve and the Joint Committee on Taxation — the entity that writes the tax code — workers below roughly the 90th income percentile at their firms saw negligible to no change in earnings from the corporate rate cut. Executives and owners, by contrast, captured over 60% of the corporate tax benefit. The top 1% alone took roughly 24%.
In 2018, S&P 500 companies spent over $800 billion buying back their own stock — a record at the time. Not factories. Not workers. Their own shares. Because when you hand corporations a permanent windfall with no accountability strings, money flows to shareholders. Every time.
Corporate tax revenue fell by roughly one-third from projections even as pretax corporate profits rose toward historic highs. The cut didn’t pay for itself. What it did was transfer $1.9 trillion in future fiscal obligations to a public that was told this was for them.
Roosevelt’s Square Deal ran on a different logic entirely: you build the guardrails because markets left unchecked concentrate wealth until the weight of concentration destabilizes the whole structure. The TCJA was not reform. It was the removal of what was left of the guardrail.
UNCOMFORTABLE TRUTH The Tax Policy Center, the Federal Reserve, and the Joint Committee on Taxation all reached variations of the same conclusion: the corporate tax cut produced no measurable wage gains for rank-and-file workers. This is not a contested number massaged by one partisan think tank. The entity that writes the tax code confirmed it. File that under things that don’t require your anger — just your attention.
Every Promise He Broke (And Who Benefited From the Breaking)
Here is the full list of things Trump promised voters in 2016 and did not deliver:
The wall. Mexico was going to pay for it. Mexico did not pay for it. The U.S. spent an estimated $15 billion. New construction covered more than 450 miles — the majority of which replaced existing, older barriers rather than closing open stretches. The singular unbroken wall was never built. Contractors got paid. The base got a bumper sticker.
Healthcare. “Repeal and replace” was the first executive order of the first day, the culmination of seven years of Republican promises, and the beneficiary of a House and Senate majority. The first repeal bill failed in the House. A modified version passed the House but died in the Senate in July 2017 when John McCain walked onto the floor and gave a thumbs down. Twenty million people kept their insurance. The promise did not survive contact with the complexity it had spent years pretending wasn’t there.
Drug prices. The pharmaceutical industry spent heavily. It didn’t happen.
Infrastructure. Infrastructure Week became Washington’s longest-running joke. Four years. No bill.
Manufacturing jobs. Business investment declined rather than surging after the tax cuts. The factories didn’t come back. The towns didn’t recover. The people who voted for this were still in the same zip codes, in the same situation, four years later.
The pattern across every broken promise is directional, not random. Every constituent-facing policy failed or evaporated. Every donor-class policy — the tax cut, the deregulation, the agency appointments, the regulatory rollbacks — passed quietly and permanently.
Incompetence is random. This wasn’t random.
PRO-TIP The First Step Act is the genuine exception. Bipartisan criminal justice reform that reduced mandatory minimums and expanded early release pathways for federal prisoners. It was real and it helped real people. It was also the one piece of legislation that aligned donor-class interest in reducing incarceration costs with constituent interest in criminal justice reform. When both sides of that equation pointed the same direction, something got built. Note when the exception occurs. It tells you how the rule works.
The Chaos Was Governance
This is the section that requires saying out loud because almost no one in political media said it clearly enough at the time.
The tweets were not a distraction from the governance. The tweets were the governance — in the specific sense that they controlled what the press covered, what the public argued about, and what Congress had to respond to on any given 48-hour cycle.
While the national conversation was consumed by Charlottesville, the Muslim ban litigation, the Comey firing, the Stormy Daniels coverage, the Ukraine call, the two impeachments — the regulatory apparatus was being systematically disassembled in the background.
Over 100 environmental regulations rolled back. The EPA’s enforcement division gutted. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau handed to a director philosophically opposed to its mission. Net neutrality killed. The Department of Labor’s overtime rules blocked. Agency leadership installed specifically to slow the agencies they ran.
None of it happened in a single dramatic moment. It happened in a thousand small regulatory actions while everyone was watching the feed.
Roosevelt used the attention of the press strategically too — but in the opposite direction. He wanted people watching when he broke Northern Securities. He wanted Morgan to know the whole country was watching. Public attention was the enforcement mechanism. The visibility was the point.
Trump inverted this completely. Public attention became the cover. The visibility of the chaos was the mechanism that kept the structural work invisible. Not incompetence. Inversion.
This is not commentary. It is a description of how the machine was operated.
The Judiciary: The Only Thing That Was Never For You
While everything else in the first term was theoretically reversible — executive orders can be revoked, regulations restored, tax cuts allowed to expire — the 226 federal judges confirmed during the first term cannot be unconfirmed.
Three Supreme Court justices. 54 appeals court judges. 174 district court judges. All lifetime appointments. All screened by the Federalist Society, which had spent forty years building exactly this infrastructure for exactly this moment. Trump didn’t create that pipeline. He was its delivery mechanism.
The downstream consequences are not hypothetical. The Dobbs decision overturning Roe v. Wade came from this Court. The presidential immunity decision that effectively ended Trump’s criminal exposure came from this Court. The gutting of Chevron deference — the legal doctrine that gave federal agencies authority to interpret their own regulations — came from this Court, and it will reduce the regulatory capacity of every future administration for decades.
This was the most disciplined, long-term-oriented project of the entire first term. It was done for a constituency that doesn’t hold rallies. It holds partner meetings.
Roosevelt built institutions to constrain the accumulation of private power. The judiciary project of the first term was designed to constrain the institutions that constrain private power. Same machinery. Opposite aim.
COVID: The Stress Test He Failed on Purpose
2020:
A pandemic arrives. 400,000 Americans die before the term ends.
Operation Warp Speed was real. Vaccine development at historic speed, cutting through bureaucratic timelines that would normally take a decade. That deserves acknowledgment.
Everything else is harder to say charitably.
The testing rollout failed. The PPE stockpile had been depleted and not replenished after prior administrations drew it down. The CDC was sidelined in favor of political messaging. Governors were pitted against each other in a bidding war for ventilators. The president told the country the virus would disappear by Easter, that it was comparable to the flu, that light and disinfectant were worth exploring.
But the deeper story is structural, not behavioral: a presidency that spent four years systematically weakening federal regulatory capacity, defunding agency expertise, and installing ideologically hostile leadership at the agencies most responsible for public health response — was then handed a crisis that required exactly the capacity it had spent four years removing.
The ideology was tested by the pathogen. The results were 400,000 dead before Inauguration Day 2021.
The people who died were disproportionately old, poor, Black, Latino, and rural — the demographics least likely to be on the donor call list and most likely to be on the campaign rally list. That’s not an accusation. It’s a distribution.
January 6 and the Exit Wound
November 3, 2020. Trump loses the election by 7 million votes and 74 electoral votes.
What follows is 77 days of the most sustained assault on democratic certification in modern American history — not by force of arms initially, but through sixty-one lawsuits (all lost), sustained public pressure on state officials, direct calls to the Georgia Secretary of State asking him to “find” votes, and the exploitation of every procedural ambiguity that hadn’t anticipated someone trying to use it this way.
Attorney General Barr said publicly there was no evidence of fraud sufficient to change the outcome. Three Trump-appointed Supreme Court justices declined to hear the cases. His own vice president informed him the Constitution provided no mechanism to block certification.
On January 6, 2021, a mob attacked the Capitol while Congress certified results. Seven people died in connection with it. Over 1,200 were eventually charged. Trump watched on television for hours.
He was impeached for the second time. Acquitted for the second time. Banned from major platforms. Exiled to Mar-a-Lago.
Washington exhaled. The system had held. The guardrails had worked. The press declared it over.
And Trump — watching the entire machinery of consequence fail to produce a consequence — took notes.
What the System Thought It Won
Here is the lesson the system drew from the first term: The institutions held. The courts held. The election held. Democracy is resilient. The norms bent but didn’t break.
Here is the lesson Trump drew: Every person who told him no still had their job. Every prosecutor who investigated him was still a prosecutor. Every court that ruled against him still had jurisdiction. The machine that was supposed to stop him had spent four years showing him, in precise detail, exactly where it was slow, deferential, afraid of its own precedents, and most importantly — where its personnel could be replaced.
He didn’t leave office defeated. He left office with a blueprint.
Roosevelt built the regulatory and judicial scaffolding of a modern state because he understood that power without direction becomes predatory. The first term’s real legacy is not the chaos, the tweets, or the broken promises. It’s what a patient man learned about where the scaffolding was weakest.
UNCOMFORTABLE TRUTH A system that bends without breaking teaches the person bending it exactly how far it goes. The institutions held. They also handed a detailed technical manual to the one person with both the motive and the future opportunity to use it. That’s not pessimism. That’s just what happened.
And Finally…
The Thing Nobody Wanted to Say Out Loud
When Roosevelt left office, he left behind a Forest Service, a consumer protection framework, 44 broken monopolies, and 194 million acres of locked public land. He left the country with more capacity than he found it with.
When Trump left in January 2021, he left behind a tax code permanently tilted toward corporate ownership. A federal judiciary reshaped for a generation. A dozen regulatory agencies functionally weakened. An insurrection that nobody was charged with organizing. And 74 million voters who had been told, for four years, that every institution standing between them and their grievances was an enemy — and who watched those institutions fail to hold anyone accountable.
The system bent. The system survived. The system congratulated itself.
The system had no idea what it had just trained.
The system bent but didn’t snap. That mattered more than anyone realized at the time. Because it taught everyone watching exactly how far the next attempt could go.
Four years of restraint followed. It looked like stability. It functioned like incubation. Every unanswered question became a future justification. And the system never noticed it was building its own return problem.
Up Next — Part Two: The Waiting Years · Biden, the Martyr Factory & the System That Blinked (2021–2024)
THE THREE TRUMPS · Full Series
Prologue — Power With Purpose · Theodore Roosevelt & the Standard We No Longer Meet
Part One — The Audition · Trump Term One (2017–2021)
Part Two — The Waiting Years · Biden, the Martyr Factory & the System That Blinked (2021–2024)
Part Three — The Revenge Tour · Power Without Restraint (2025–Present)
Uncomfortable runs on spite, caffeine, and whatever cash you feel like throwing at it. No sponsors. No corporate sugar daddies. No algorithm to lick. If this piece made your blood boil or your brain spark — good. That’s the point. Any contribution that you give will help me to pay to expose this to as many eyeballs as possible. This is a group movement, and I’m doing the writing, and I’m asking you to help get the word out there so we can build a revolution. This is not hyperbole. It’s necessary.
Tip $5 · Tip $10 · Tip $20 · Tip $50 · Tip $75 · Tip $100 · Tip $250 · $500 ·
Subscribe on Substack · Buy Me a Coffee · PayPal
